Maggie’s Galley Gets a Thumbs Up

Overview
Maggie’s Galley Oyster Bar, located on the way to Waynesville from Maggie at 49 Howell Mill Rd, Waynesville, NC 28786 between Barber Blvd and US-276/Dellwood Rd, sits off the main road and hardly appears to be a restaurant. Constructed of reclaimed lumber as much as 175 years old, this quaint building houses an unexpected delightful place for dining. With an expansive menu of seafood to choose from there is something for everyone. Our server was pleasant, informative, but unobtrusive. The food was served in a timely manner.

Our Meal
Mark sampled the grilled grouper sandwich with cole slaw and french fries which he enjoyed. Served on a grilled onion roll, the fish was mild and flavorful. I tried the crabcake sandwich served on the same delicious onion roll. The crabcake was moist and flavorful but a bit light on crab. I chose the twice baked potato as my side. Unfortunately, unlike the perfectly prepared french fries, my potato came out with a hard crust on the top instead of the soft, lightly browned mashed potato it should have been. For desert we sampled a coca cola cake, chocolate cake made with cola. It was served warm with fresh whipped cream. We were underwhelmed by it as the icing once warmed just tasted like a gritty chocolate sugar.

The Menu and Online Reviews
Maggie’s Galley Oyster BarThe menu also has a large choice of foods for the landlubber to include chicken, burgers, and steaks. Although occasionally Maggie’s Galley gets lambasted, online reviews that I read overwhelmingly give Maggie Galley’s high scores.

Summary
We would definitely return to this moderately priced and pleasant restaurant. I would just avoid the twice baked potato and check out some of the other landlubber choices. As always with restaurants in and around Haywood County check times as many restaurants are closed at least one day a week. Times vary depending on the tourist season.